The two most important risks of thyroid surgery are injury to the nerves that move the vocal folds and to the parathyroid glands, which regulate calcium in the blood. We use two technologies in our operations to protect these structures:
- Intraoperative nerve monitoring: The location and function of the vocal fold nerves (the recurrent laryngeal nerves) are checked throughout the operation with electrical stimulation, making the nerve easier to find and protect.
- Fluorescence imaging of the parathyroid glands (NIRAF and ICG): Near-infrared autofluorescence (NIRAF) helps to identify the parathyroid glands during surgery, and indocyanine green (ICG) angiography helps to assess their blood supply. The aim is to reduce the risk of low calcium after surgery.
Prof. M. Kürşat Gökcan is among the pioneers in Türkiye of nerve monitoring in thyroid surgery and of fluorescence imaging to preserve the parathyroid glands.
He trained in 2006–2007 with Dr. Gregory W. Randolph in the Division of Thyroid and Parathyroid Surgery at Massachusetts Eye and Ear Infirmary, Harvard Medical School; published a Turkish-language review of intraoperative recurrent laryngeal nerve monitoring in 2009; supervised a residency thesis on revision thyroid surgery under neural monitoring in 2016; and wrote the book chapter “Neuromonitoring in thyroid surgery” in 2021.
Intraoperative recurrent laryngeal nerve monitoring
Total thyroidectomy is perhaps the only operation in head and neck surgery that carries a risk of injury to a cranial nerve (one of the nerves arising from the brain) on both sides, and because this concerns the airway it is a vital risk. Bilateral recurrent laryngeal nerve (RLN) paralysis, that is, paralysis of both vocal folds, is uncommon, but because of the severity of its consequences it remains one of the most feared complications of thyroid and parathyroid surgery.
Thyroid surgery has continued to evolve since it was first performed around 500 BC. Until the mid-1800s patients were lost to bleeding and infection; from the 1920s the literature turns from the mortality of the procedure to its complications, such as RLN injury and postoperative hypocalcaemia (low blood calcium).
Since Lahey, the golden rule for avoiding RLN injury has been to identify the nerve and dissect it along its course (carefully freeing it from the surrounding tissue so that it can be seen). Many researchers have sought to reduce RLN injury by defining the nerve’s relationship to anatomical landmarks such as the tracheo-oesophageal groove (the groove between the windpipe and the oesophagus), the inferior thyroid artery (the lower artery of the thyroid), Berry’s ligament (the ligament that attaches the thyroid to the windpipe) and the tubercle of Zuckerkandl (a projection on the back of the thyroid). The importance of these relationships for identifying the nerve and performing a safe thyroidectomy cannot be denied. Yet even the most reliable landmark may be displaced or unrecognisable in revision surgery (repeat operations), in large goitres and in patients who have had radiotherapy. Anatomical variations such as a non-recurrent nerve (a rare situation in which the nerve takes an unusual course), branching of the RLN outside the larynx, and the changed appearance of tissues during bleeding mean that nerve injury can occur even in the most experienced hands. Moreover, despite every effort to preserve the nerve’s integrity, nerve conduction may be impaired by axonal injury (damage to the nerve fibres) caused by pressure, stretching, crushing, heat (during bipolar coagulation, in which vessels are sealed with electrical current to stop bleeding) or ischaemia (impaired blood supply). Additional techniques to help identify the nerve and check its function have therefore come to the fore.
Intraoperative nerve monitoring (IONM) has become increasingly widespread in recent years in head and neck surgery and in otology–neurotology (surgery of the ear and its nerves), to identify cranial nerves and reduce the risk of injury during dissection. The devices generally used today record spontaneous or evoked nerve activity during the operation as electromyography (EMG; a recording of the electrical activity of muscle) from the muscle supplied by the nerve, through surface or needle electrodes.
RLN monitoring has three specific functions during thyroidectomy:
- To make the nerve easier to identify
- To give feedback by monitoring spontaneous EMG activity while the nerve is being dissected (warning the surgeon when the nerve is under strain)
- To give prognostic information about nerve function at the end of the operation (predicting how the voice will be afterwards)
While the nerve is being sought, the monitor indicates its position wherever it is stimulated with the probe along its likely course, making it easier to identify. It is known that only a very small proportion of RLN paralyses after thyroidectomy are caused by division of the nerve; usually there is axonal injury even though the nerve sheath is intact. Perhaps the most important function of IONM is therefore that it allows electrophysiological measurements (measurements of the nerve’s electrical conduction) that confirm the nerve is working, so that bilateral RLN paralysis is not encountered after surgery.
Nerve monitoring is regarded as standard in parotid (the salivary gland in front of the ear) and neurotological procedures. Evidence-based medicine, by contrast, does not consider monitoring essential for standard cases in thyroid and parathyroid surgery; the gold standard for preventing RLN injury is still identification of the nerve and dissection along its course.
IONM is reported to be indicated particularly where the risk of RLN injury is increased: cancer surgery, central neck dissection (clearance of the lymph nodes around the thyroid), surgery for Graves’ disease and thyroiditis, surgery for substernal goitre (goitre extending into the chest), revision surgery, and surgery in patients who have had radiotherapy. IONM should always be considered when operating on the side of the only functioning nerve. Prof. Kürşat Gökcan has adopted the principle of routine intraoperative nerve monitoring in thyroid surgery. We believe that every surgeon whose work is mainly thyroid and parathyroid surgery should have a nerve monitor in the operating theatre and be familiar with its use. We also consider that routine use of IONM in every case, with the recordings kept alongside the operation note, can serve as evidence of the care taken.